During my divorce process, I found myself questioning whether buying a home was financially feasible. I explored both renting and purchasing options to gauge my monthly expenses and long-term financial outlook. With two children, a teenager and a preteen, I needed at least three bedrooms, which significantly limited my choices, particularly for rentals.
The upfront costs of buying a home were higher than renting. For a property priced at $180,000, I’d need approximately $36,000 for a down payment, plus additional funds for closing costs. In contrast, for renting a three-bedroom apartment, which started at $1,500 per month, I’d need $4,500 upfront for first and last month’s rent along with a security deposit.
Yet, on a monthly basis, renting was much more expensive—about 50% more than owning. A 20% down payment on that $180,000 home would result in a mortgage payment, including property taxes and homeowners insurance, of around $1,040 per month. In comparison, the cheapest rental was $1,500.
While owning a home does come with its own set of costs, I argue that renting is ultimately a financial dead end. With each mortgage payment, part of the funds contribute to the home’s equity, which I can reclaim when I sell. Over time, as I pay down the mortgage, my equity grows. In contrast, every cent spent on rent enriches someone else, and I never see any of that money again.
Furthermore, many financial analyses comparing renting and buying overlook the potential returns after several years of homeownership and the profits that come from selling a house. Homeownership is often one of the most dependable methods for building wealth—it’s akin to having a savings account that earns interest. The opportunity cost of renting is considerable, especially since rental prices have risen sharply.
For many, the reality of rising rents means they remain trapped in a cycle of renting, unable to save for a home. The prevailing narrative suggests that young individuals can save for a down payment by renting a low-cost place and stashing away extra income. However, if all potential savings are consumed by exorbitant rental payments, how can anyone realistically build that nest egg?
With my income, had I been forced to rent, I would have struggled to save even a couple hundred dollars monthly. At that rate, it would take me 15 years to accumulate enough for a down payment. However, by then, home prices would likely have surged, requiring even more than I would have needed just a few years ago. In fact, home prices have escalated so much recently that I would now need nearly $6,000 more for a down payment than I would have two years ago.
This scenario raises an important question: how can one save the necessary 20% down payment when renting is often 50% more expensive than buying? A quick glance at listings on Zillow reveals that rental premiums significantly hinder saving efforts. Additionally, because of the rental market dynamics and the ability of property owners to profit from short-term rentals via sites like Airbnb, many affordable properties are being snapped up by investors, further complicating opportunities for first-time buyers.
This issue contributes to the widening wealth gap. Rising home and rental prices mean that without financial support, many will find it increasingly difficult to afford a roof over their heads. The only reason I was able to buy my first home back in 2008 was due to the generosity of a relative who allowed me to live rent-free for a year, enabling me to save $25,000. That year laid the foundation for my net worth growth, eventually leading me to a home with equity. Unfortunately, many Americans lack such support.
While we address the pressing issues of healthcare costs and educational inequities, we often overlook the crisis of housing affordability. Millions are being priced out of even the most basic necessity: shelter.
For further insights, check out this other post on our blog here, and for authoritative information on home insemination, visit Make a Mom. Additionally, WebMD is an excellent resource for pregnancy and home insemination.