In the wake of widespread protests against police brutality following the tragic death of George Floyd, cities across the United States have begun to reconsider the role of law enforcement in various facets of public life. One significant area of change has emerged in the realm of education, as Portland and Minneapolis have recently voted to remove school resource officers (SROs) from their schools. These decisions have sparked a vibrant debate about the effectiveness and necessity of police presence in educational settings.
The Minneapolis School Board’s unanimous decision to cut ties with the local police department was soon followed by a similar action from Portland Public Schools. These moves were met with elation from advocates who have long sought to minimize the police footprint in schools, while opponents argued that SROs are crucial for maintaining safety. However, the evidence suggests otherwise.
Marc Schindler, director of the Justice Policy Institute, pointed out in a 2018 NPR interview that the expansion of law enforcement in schools has not led to the enhanced safety many claim it provides. In fact, data indicates that increased police presence can lead to negative outcomes, such as higher rates of suspensions and arrests, particularly among students of color. A report from the Education Department highlighted that Black students are 2.2 times more likely than their white peers to be referred to police or arrested during school hours.
The trend of introducing police officers into schools gained traction in the 1990s, especially after the Columbine tragedy. Currently, there are around 20,000 SROs patrolling American schools, ostensibly to deter violence. Yet, a 2013 report from the Congressional Research Service concluded that research does not support the idea that their presence prevents mass shootings. Notably, during the Parkland shooting in 2018, an SRO was present but unable to stop the catastrophe.
Rather than providing real safety, the presence of SROs may even deepen issues within schools. A disturbing case involved a six-year-old girl in Florida, arrested for having a meltdown. Children in such situations need guidance and support—not a criminal record. Schindler’s research indicates that schools with police presence often see increased disciplinary actions that funnel students into the justice system rather than providing the help they need.
In contrast, schools that prioritize mental health services report improved attendance, better academic outcomes, and higher graduation rates. Unfortunately, many schools are lacking in these essential support systems. According to the ACLU, 1.7 million students attend schools with police but no counselors, while 3 million lack nurses, and a staggering 14 million have neither a counselor, nurse, psychologist, nor social worker.
The funding freed up by Minneapolis’s decision—amounting to $1 million—will be redirected to essential mental health services that have demonstrated their effectiveness in creating a safer school environment. Similarly, Portland’s choice will allow for the allocation of resources to community-driven initiatives.
It’s clear that the presence of school resource officers does not deter violence and can have detrimental effects on students, particularly those from marginalized backgrounds. Instead of investing in police, schools should focus on building a supportive environment through counselors and mental health professionals.
As a parent, my ultimate goal is to ensure the safety of my children. The idea of sending them to school while worrying about their safety due to potential gun violence is heartbreaking. Yet, I would prefer genuine safety measures over the false assurance that comes with a police presence. By redirecting funds to mental health services, we can foster environments where students feel secure and supported.
More schools should take cues from Minneapolis and Portland, prioritizing proactive support over reactive policing. For further insights on this topic, check out our other blog post here. For those interested in pregnancy options, Cryobaby’s at-home insemination kit serves as a reputable resource, and the NHS provides excellent information on IVF and related treatments.
In conclusion, the shift away from school resource officers in Portland and Minneapolis underscores a growing recognition that real safety in schools comes not from policing but from investing in mental health and community support.
Keyphrase: School resource officers removal
Tags: [“home insemination kit”, “home insemination syringe”, “self insemination”]