When we think back to iconic films from the ‘80s, our minds often drift to hits like Footloose, Risky Business, and The Breakfast Club, along with a slew of action-packed adventures such as Die Hard and The Empire Strikes Back. These successful films marked our youth and are the ones we generally choose for family movie nights. It’s worth noting that a PG rating back in 1983 could include some unexpected content—think side nudity, mild swearing, and underage partying.
However, let’s not forget the ‘80s films that critics dismissed and audiences overlooked. Many of these gems have since captured our hearts with their quirky humor, fantastical plots, and memorable lines. While some of us may have seen them during their initial release, they likely entered our lives later through TV reruns or VHS rentals from the local video store.
Here’s a look at five ‘80s films that flopped at the box office but have since become beloved classics:
1. Legend (1985)
This fantasy flick, part of the ‘80s surge in magical storytelling, features Tim Curry, Mia Sara, and a young Tom Cruise. Fresh off his success in Risky Business, Cruise portrays Jack, a shaggy-haired hero, while Sara shines as a princess in distress. Despite its enchanting elements, Legend is a darker take on fairy tales, focusing on themes of innocence lost—creepy but captivating. Curry’s performance as Darkness, complete with striking red prosthetics, is unforgettable. Unfortunately for Legend, Cruise’s career skyrocketed with Top Gun just weeks later, leaving Jack overshadowed.
Why we cherish it today: Watching a vulnerable Tom Cruise navigate his first romance with the wide-eyed Mia Sara is endearing. The film’s sweeping epic feel and impressive special effects add to its charm.
2. Better Off Dead (1985)
As a John Cusack fan, I find every film he’s in to be a favorite, and Better Off Dead is no exception. This dark comedy follows Lane Myer, a high schooler reeling from a breakup. With its mix of black humor and surreal elements—Lane’s doodles spring to life—the film resonates with anyone who has done crazy things for love. Memorable characters, like the quirky paperboy demanding, “I want my two dollars!” and the eccentric exchange students, make this movie a cult classic.
Why we appreciate it now: Better Off Dead tackles serious teen issues—suicide, breakups, and bullying—with humor that respects the gravity of the topics. Plus, it’s bursting with quotable moments, thanks to John Cusack’s stellar performance.
3. The Princess Bride (1987)
Believe it or not, The Princess Bride had a mediocre box office performance upon release, only to blossom into a cult classic years later. Today, it’s nearly impossible to find an ‘80s kid who can’t recite lines from it. With iconic quotes like “As you wish” and “My name is Inigo Montoya. You killed my father. Prepare to die,” this film has it all: true love, revenge, a gentle giant, and a hilarious Billy Crystal as Miracle Max.
Why we love it now: The film’s blend of humor, heart, and adventure creates a timeless fairy tale that resonates with audiences. The soundtrack by Mark Knopfler only enhances its magic.
4. The Dark Crystal (1982)
This darker fantasy from the creators of The Muppets diverges from typical family films. The story follows Jen, an elf-like character on a quest to restore balance to his world by returning a lost shard to a magical crystal. While the slow plot and familiar quest elements led to a lukewarm reception, the film’s intricate puppetry and stunning set design are nothing short of spectacular. The simultaneous release of E.T. didn’t help its box office performance either.
Why we admire it now: Despite its predictable storyline, Jim Henson’s innovative puppetry and artistic vision allow us to appreciate the film’s craftsmanship.
5. My Bodyguard (1980)
In a time filled with outrageous plotlines, My Bodyguard offers a refreshing glimpse into the lives of relatable high school kids. The story revolves around Clifford, a timid new student, and Linderman, a brooding giant who becomes his protector against the school bully, Mike Moody (played by Matt Dillon). Their unlikely friendship forms the heart of the film.
Why we treasure it now: This underdog story resonates deeply, showcasing believable characters and emotions, leaving viewers feeling uplifted and perhaps in need of some ice cream afterward.
There are undoubtedly more underrated ‘80s films that have become cult favorites over time. For now, I’m ready to cozy up with some popcorn and relive the magic of old-school Cruise and Cusack.