In a troubling turn of events, the Boy Scouts of America are now facing a lawsuit after demoting a teenager with Down syndrome, named Ethan Miller, who has been a dedicated member since he was eight. At 15, Ethan was enthusiastically preparing to earn his Eagle Scout rank this year, but his aspirations took a hit when the national organization rejected his Eagle project proposal and invalidated 22 of his previously earned merit badges.
Ethan had completed alternative merit badges, which are specifically designed for scouts who may not be able to fulfill traditional badge requirements due to physical or mental disabilities. According to the Boy Scouts’ guidelines, scouts with such challenges can still aim for the Eagle Scout rank by qualifying for these alternative badges. However, the sudden decision to disregard Ethan’s badges has relegated him back to Cub Scout status, typically reserved for children aged 10 and under.
This unfortunate situation unfolded after Ethan submitted a project proposal to create newborn kits for a local hospital, which was initially approved by his local troop. His father, Tom Miller, shared that the local chapter even celebrated the approval with a photo of Ethan in full uniform. However, when the project reached the national office, it faced suspension. Subsequently, the Millers learned that Ethan’s previously earned merit badges had been declared void, despite having been approved by local leaders who had adjusted requirements to accommodate him.
In response to this distressing turn of events, the Miller family is now pursuing legal action against the Boy Scouts of America, seeking $1 million in damages along with reinstatement for Ethan. “We have yet to hear back from the Boy Scouts regarding the lawsuit,” Tom Miller stated. Yet, the family is receiving an outpouring of support from the community, with many individuals offering their own Eagle Scout honors to Ethan. “I am truly humbled by the generosity of people here in Utah!” he expressed.
For those interested in more information about alternative family-building options, check out our post on at-home insemination kits, which provides valuable insights. Additionally, Modern Family Blog has an extensive article discussing the topic in greater detail, making it a good read. You can also find excellent resources for pregnancy and donor insemination at American Pregnancy.
In summary, this case highlights the challenges and injustices faced by individuals with disabilities within organizations that are meant to promote inclusivity. The Millers are advocating not only for Ethan but also for the recognition and respect all scouts deserve, regardless of their needs.