As a journalist who has spent the past year covering the U.S. government’s response to the pandemic, I was hoping for clearer guidance from my doctor. When I inquired about whether I should receive the COVID-19 vaccine while pregnant, his response was vague: “It’s a personal choice.” While I understood his position, it left me searching for more substantial information.
Like many Americans, I found that the consensus among medical and scientific experts is a resounding “Yes!” regarding vaccine safety and efficacy, but the guidance for pregnant women is often muddled. The initial trials for these vaccines excluded pregnant and breastfeeding individuals, which is a common practice due to the complexities involved in evaluating the health of both mother and baby.
This cautious approach stems from historical precedents, such as the thalidomide tragedy, which led to stricter guidelines in clinical trials. In January, the World Health Organization advised against vaccination for pregnant women, a stance that later changed to align more closely with the CDC’s recommendations, which encourage individualized decision-making.
This lack of clear guidance complicates the decision-making process for expecting mothers. I am neither a scientist nor a medical professional, but my journalistic background allows me to thoroughly research and consult experts. Here’s how I navigated my decision-making process.
Establishing a Framework
I began by establishing a framework for my decision. Flipping a coin wasn’t an option; considering the well-being of myself and my unborn child, it was essential to weigh the risks and benefits. This is a common practice in medicine, akin to how doctors evaluate the risks of heart surgery against the potential consequences of not proceeding.
Dr. Rachel Thompson, an expert in gynecology at a local university, emphasized the rigorous safety evaluations that the vaccines underwent. After extensive trials involving tens of thousands of participants, independent experts assessed the safety data for both the FDA and CDC. Professional organizations, such as the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology, then recommended making vaccines available to pregnant women. “It’s a thorough process, and ongoing evaluations continue to affirm safety,” Dr. Thompson noted.
Evaluating the Risks
Next, I looked into the risks associated with the vaccine. Although we lack extensive clinical trial data on pregnant women, prior studies show that the vaccines did not harm pregnant animals. Real-world evidence is increasingly reassuring: Nearly 78,000 individuals in the U.S. reported vaccination during pregnancy without adverse effects on mothers or babies. “That’s quite convincing,” said Dr. Mark Anderson, a maternal-fetal medicine expert. The CDC’s analysis indicated that vaccinated pregnant individuals experienced normal side effects and faced no greater risk of complications than those who were not vaccinated.
Furthermore, experts have noted no biological reason to believe that the mRNA vaccines (like those from Pfizer and Moderna) or the Johnson & Johnson vaccine would adversely affect pregnancy. The Johnson & Johnson vaccine’s technology was safely used in an Ebola vaccine during pregnancy. Pregnant individuals have routinely received various vaccines over the years, and the coronavirus vaccines do not contain live virus; they instead stimulate the immune system to produce antibodies.
Considering the Implications
Given the positive signs, I found the current guidance from organizations like the CDC to be overly cautious. More studies on vaccinated pregnant women are forthcoming, and Dr. Thompson believes that in the near future, recommendations will align more closely with those for other vaccines, like influenza and TDAP, which are routinely administered during pregnancy.
I also considered the implications of not getting vaccinated. Research indicates that pregnant women infected with COVID-19 face a higher risk of severe illness, hospitalization, or complications during childbirth. While over 60 million Americans are fully vaccinated, the emergence of highly transmissible variants posed a continued risk. “You don’t want to be the last person vulnerable to infection,” Dr. Thompson warned.
Weighing the Benefits
Weighing the potential benefits on both sides, I recognized that avoiding the vaccine might spare me from rare complications, but the benefits of vaccination were substantial: protection against severe illness, potential antibody transfer to my child, contributing to community immunity, and a return to normalcy with reduced risk of transmission to vulnerable populations.
I also took my personal circumstances into account. Quarantining completely until the pandemic ended was impractical and detrimental to my mental health. After a year of virtual gatherings, I wanted to celebrate my sister’s graduation and attend my cousin’s wedding.
Ultimately, I chose to get vaccinated. The advantages of vaccination outweighed the uncertain risks, and the dangers of contracting COVID-19 during pregnancy were too significant to ignore. I received my first dose of the Pfizer vaccine and enrolled in the CDC’s v-safe program to monitor the vaccine’s impact on pregnancy and childbirth.
I hope that the data collected will provide future guidance for expectant mothers.
Further Resources
For further insights on pregnancy and home insemination, check out this resource and explore more about home insemination. If you’re considering artificial insemination, visit Make a Mom for a comprehensive guide.