As a parent, one of the dilemmas you may face is whether to encourage your child to study music, even if they show minimal enthusiasm. Recently, my 5-year-old son, Alex, began violin lessons, but his reaction has been rather lukewarm. My partner and I both have musical backgrounds, often playing and singing at home, which means Alex has been exposed to a variety of melodies since he was a baby. Despite expressing interest in the lessons after receiving a hand-me-down violin from a friend, during his first lesson, he seemed hesitant and only reluctantly echoed the instructor’s melodies. It’s uncertain if he will continue or dedicate enough practice time to truly benefit from the lessons.
My partner, Ryan, and I have differing opinions about whether to require him to stick with the lessons. I believe that learning to play an instrument, understand musical notation, and develop auditory skills from an early age is an invaluable gift, even if Alex doesn’t currently recognize its value. I advocate for making lessons and practice a regular part of his routine, regardless of his immediate interests. In contrast, Ryan feels that music should be a source of joy and that children should engage at their own pace and comfort level.
Both of us draw from our own experiences with music during childhood. We both took lessons in violin and piano but were never coerced into practicing and were allowed to discontinue when we wished. Ryan picked up the guitar as an adult and has excelled, while I continue to struggle as a beginner. He appreciates his musical journey without regret over stopping lessons, whereas I sometimes wish my mother had encouraged me more persistently. Reflecting on this, I realize that it may not be easy to compel a child to invest the time and effort needed to excel.
Currently, we aim to keep music enjoyable, engaging in family sing-alongs and creating silly songs together. Alex is quick to detect when we attempt to turn play into structured lessons, such as when I refer to scales as the “numbers song.” For now, he prefers songs about trains. We also recognize the psychology of a 5-year-old; he can stay up 20 minutes later than his younger brother if he chooses to sing or play a song with us. Furthermore, the violin is his “special possession,” off-limits to his brother.
Music should remain a source of enjoyment. I’m unsure why I didn’t appreciate music in my youth but now find great joy in it. Ryan suggests it’s because, as adults, we have the autonomy to choose our instructors, select our music, and control our practice schedules—something children typically lack. If Alex decides against the violin, he can explore other instruments or simply enjoy singing with us. Regardless of his choices, I hope he remains an engaged listener, allowing music to enrich his life long-term.
In summary, while the decision to force a child into music lessons can be contentious, it is essential to weigh the benefits of musical education against the child’s interests and autonomy. Ultimately, fostering a love for music in a supportive, pressure-free environment may lead to a more fulfilling relationship with music in the future.
Keyphrase: Encourage child music lessons
Tags: home insemination kit, home insemination syringe, self insemination