While I may have aged out of the target demographic, I find myself drawn to the series Girls, primarily due to Lena Dunham’s central role. My interest isn’t sparked by the plotlines, which bear little relevance to my life as a wife and mother. Nor do I seek a connection to youth culture—I encounter it daily and certainly don’t crave more of it—or the handmade hipster aesthetic that suffocates many in Brooklyn.
What captivates me is Dunham’s skill as a writer and her character Hannah’s relentless pursuit of artistic authenticity. I appreciate her tendency to gaze up at the ceiling while conversing, as well as her knack for both mocking and embracing pretentiousness—something many individuals can relate to, regardless of age. Hannah’s struggle with the fear of fraudulence, coupled with her moments of confidence, resonates with me. Having exhibited similar foolishness during my own MFA journey, I relished Hannah’s workshop scenes in Iowa—laughing, cringing, and reminiscing about my past follies.
My enjoyment of the show remains intact, even though I’ve moved beyond the casual romances, the excitement, and the heartbreaks that are unique to a woman in her twenties. My current indignities (like those unexpected hairs) and joys (such as cozy nights on the couch) reflect the life of someone far older than Hannah. Yet, I am eager to continue exploring Dunham’s perspective, which is witty, intelligent, and often anxious. My interest stems not solely from Hannah’s relationships or quirks, but from Dunham’s journey as an artist and as a woman.
When a writer possesses the ability to reflect critically yet compassionately on herself while envisioning her future self, the outcome is profound. As long as Dunham maintains this introspective lens, I will be intrigued by her endeavors—most recently, an HBO documentary she executive produced with Sarah Lawson. Titled It’s Me, Clara, the film premieres on March 23rd.
Directed by Tom Reed, the documentary focuses on Charles Quinn, the illustrator behind the beloved Eloise series penned by Kay Thompson. It delves into the disintegration of the creative and personal partnership between Quinn and Thompson, as well as the painful consequences that followed. This narrative may be unfamiliar to many fans of the series. Dunham appears in the film, sharing how Quinn’s illustrations significantly impacted her.
Dunham’s childhood admiration for Eloise—she even sports an Eloise tattoo on her lower back—reflects her connection to a character who “doesn’t mind that her stomach spills over her skirt.” It seems that Dunham’s decision to create a documentary about Quinn is also driven by a desire to portray an artist whose early success was as remarkable as her own. She likely contemplates the notion that even the most talented individuals can face unforeseen setbacks. The anxiety of losing what you cherish is something I, too, have come to understand in middle age. Quinn illustrates that a vital part of his creative spirit was taken from him.
At 88 years old, witty and eccentric, Quinn continues creating films in his backyard, feeling thwarted yet motivated to produce more. His collaboration with Thompson, the success of the Eloise books, and their bitter separation create a poignant narrative about the complexities of artistic relationships. We learn that Thompson’s commanding presence often overshadowed Quinn, causing him to feel he faded into the background. Though he channeled his emotions into his artwork, it became apparent that Thompson resented the fact that her text was often overshadowed by Quinn’s illustrations.
Dunham poignantly remarks that it felt like “two people got divorced, fighting over their child, Eloise.” To Quinn’s deep regret, he consented to terms early on that barred him from illustrating Eloise, or anything resembling her, independent of Kay Thompson. Even after Thompson’s passing, contentious interactions with her estate have complicated his involvement in future Eloise projects. Despite a career filled with illustrating other books and designing stunning theater posters, Quinn has never recaptured the success of Eloise.
In the documentary, renowned author Fran Lebowitz offers a silver lining on Quinn’s experiences. Although it was disheartening and unjust for him to be excluded from the world of Eloise, she asserts, “He created something that endured. Very few things last. He made something beautiful that will persist, and that is incredibly rare.”
This sentiment is likely significant to an ambitious and contemplative artist like Dunham. She reveals that her affection for Eloise stemmed from recognizing a character with “a sense of belonging, and an understanding that she has every right to exist in her world.” As someone who has garnered her share of acclaim, it appears Dunham aims to honor another deserving artist whose contributions have been overlooked—and perhaps, will remain so.
In summary, Lena Dunham’s connection to the story of Eloise and her creator Charles Quinn reflects her understanding of the complexities of artistic life. Through her documentary, she pays tribute to a fellow artist while exploring themes of validation and the struggles inherent in creative partnerships.
Keyphrase: Lena Dunham’s Eloise Documentary
Tags: home insemination kit, home insemination syringe, self insemination